Friday, June 10, 2022

If Roe Is Overturned, Abortion Battles Have Just Begun

Print Friendly Version of this pagePrint Get a PDF version of this webpagePDF

"When states are red, but cities are blue, abortion battles begin anew," Joshua Arnold.

Fearful that the Supreme Court will overturn Roe v. Wade and send abortion policy back to the states, some pro-abortion officials in some progressive cities are preparing to draw it down to the local level.

At that point, a true civil war will have begun over the issue: "Should one human being have the right to kill another human being?"

Be informed, not misled.

The brewing battle.

Austin, Texas City Council member Chito Vela has proposed the "Guarding the Right to Abortion  Care for Everyone Act---creating the acronym "GRACE", an interesting approach to killing unwanted unborn babies.

Vela’s resolution would be introduced only if the Supreme Court overturns Roe v. Wade, writes Texas Right to Life. If passed, it would “block the use of city staff and money from investigating or reporting illegal abortions and direct the Austin Police Department to set enforcement of Pro-Life laws as its lowest priority.”

Joshua Arnold has written an excellent article on the matter. In it he says:

The phrase “lowest priority” illustrates the slippery way pro-abortion officials are trying to have the issue both ways. To defend their policies to the general public or in any legal fight, they will claim to simply be prioritizing more urgent police matters.

Orleans Parish District Attorney Jason Rogers Williams in New Orleans wrote that he “will not shift the priority from tackling shootings, rapes, and carjackings to investigating the choices women make with regard to their own bodies.” (While common, his description of abortion is inaccurate because abortion ends the life of an unborn child, who is an entirely separate and distinct person from his or her mother.)

But progressive officials expose their real motives when virtue signaling to their own base, by claiming that they are defending abortion or declaring themselves a “sanctuary city” for abortion.

It's pure irony that the leftist abortion movement is suddenly looking out for the police whom they most often curse and work to defund. And it's a good PR strategy because handling violent crime already has stretched most law enforcement beyond their limits in this age of lawlessness.

And most pro-life people are also strong supporters of law enforcement.

The new civil war.

 Arnold notes that "The pro-abortion campaign reaches far beyond Austin. Progressive city and county officials have vowed to ignore or deprioritize pro-life state laws in DeKalb County, Georgia (parts of Atlanta); Orleans Parish, Louisiana (New Orleans); Durham County, North Carolina; Radnor Township, Pennsylvania (a suburb of Philadelphia); Davidson County, Tennessee (Nashville);  and Fairfax County, Virginia (a suburb of Washington, D.C.)."

He continues, "They join more than 60 elected officials at the state and local levels who in October 2020 signed a letter organized by the progressive advocacy group Fair and Just Prosecution that said they would not prosecute abortion 'even if the protections of Roe v. Wade were eroded or overturned'.”

Clearly, pro-abortion city officials are setting up an interesting “state versus local” legal showdown if Roe v. Wade is indeed overturned. Unlike a “state versus federal” showdown, only states have sovereignty, while local governments derive their existence from the state. Local ordinances protecting abortion cannot override state laws prohibiting it, but it may be impossible, as a practical matter, for states to enforce these laws in cities where local governments and police departments are not cooperating.

It's also clear that pro-abortion forces are committed to preserving their holy grail even if Roe v. Wade is overturned. They will fight for the right to kill the unborn in Congress, in state legislatures, and even down to local city ordinances and district attorney prosecutorial discretion.

The call.

Arnold says, "It would be a shame if the pro-life movement, which worked so hard for decades to overturn Roe, suddenly gave up when it finally had an opportunity to protect unborn children. Vigilance is needed against this lawlessness, now more than ever."

The other obvious takeaway is that local elections will matter more after Roe than they have for decades.

So what does this mean?

If an elected official like a district attorney or city council member has the power to functionally determine whether abortion is forbidden or permitted in your city or county, then it’s your duty to know what your elected officials really stand for and vote according to your values. This will make the pro-life movement’s impact on life more tangible and more localized. Every member of the team will be needed on the field. No exceptions.

Be Informed. Be Engaged. Be Mindful. Be Bold. Be Prayerful.